Group asks for strong payday loan law or nothing at all
April 13, 2006 - Portland, Oregon
A group pushing a ballot initiative to rein in payday loan practices is urging the coming special legislative session to avoid the issue if proposals are weaker than what their initiative outlines.
The ballot proposal sponsored by Oregon for Payday Loan Fairne$$ would limit payday loan interest to 36 percent a year, restrict loan initiation fees to 10 percent of the loan amount it, allow only two rollovers and give borrowers 31 days instead of 15 to use the money before the loan comes due.
Oregon now is one of only seven states with no interest cap.
Gov. Ted Kulongoski called the April 20 special session to address school funding and a $136 million hole in the Department of Human Services budget.
It is not clear if payday loan reform will also be on the docket, but the issue has been gaining steam.
On Thursday, a Senate hearing and a news conference by the group backing the initiative put different faces on the industry, which is banned in three states. Some depicted the industry as one that fills a niche for those seeking small short-term loans. But a disabled woman who needed $150 for orthopedic shoes described being sucked into a payment and fee vortex that cost her $1,900.
Angela Martin of Oregon for Payday Loan Fairne$$ said Gov. Ted Kulongoski and the state Senate leadership agree with proposed initiative. House Speaker Karen Minnis has not endorsed the ballot proposal.
The Oregon Senate passed a regulatory bill in 2005 but the Republican-run House shelved it. The industry gave some $150,000 in campaign contributions to legislative candidates the previous fall, and Minnis and House Majority Leader Wayne Scott got $25,500 of it.
House Republicans denied suggestions that the contributions led to the bill's demise, and Minnis now says the special session should address the payday loan industry.
At Thursday's hearing, Luanne Stoltz, owner of Anyday's Payday Loans in Portland, said people who use the service "make an informed choice and know what the service will cost."
Stoltz claimed no state has restrictions as stiff as those in the initiative. If it passes, she said, it would doom the industry in Oregon, putting almost 1,000 people out of work and forcing people seeking short-term loans to Internet loans, pawnshops or illegal sources.
She said the fees her company charges work out to 469 percent a year, but said the short-term cost is low compared to bank overdraft charges or utility bill late fees.
Mark Thompson, in charge of government relations for Moneytree, which operates in several states including Oregon, said most financial institutions can't make money on small loans, and the loan companies of previous years have gone into real estate lending.
He said the payday loan industry has filled that niche.
Lenders depend heavily on fees generated by the loans, he said, and predicted that the ballot proposal would cut payday industry profits by 70 percent.
"Show me an industry that can survive that," Thompson said.
Absent the industry, he added, more people will turn to car title loans, leading to repossession and lost jobs.
But Maryann Olson, who said her income is $7,723 a year, related borrowing $150 when she found she needed orthopedic shoes.
After the maximum three 15-day roll-overs, in which a loan is renewed if it cannot be paid, she owed $176.47 and didn't have it.
"I had $150 but they wouldn't accept it," she said. So she took another payday loan to cover it and would [end] up in a cycle where she had eight loans outstanding, each taken to cover an earlier one.
She said the checks she left as collateral were sent to the bank in rapid-fire repetitions, resulting on overdraw fees of nearly $900 in two months.
Rev. Mark Knutson of Portland's Augusta Lutheran Church, said the businesses in Oregon make about 2,000 loans a day.
He said it is true there is a need, but the poor need fair lending practices.
"Every day we see more people struggling to make it," he said. "The last thing they need is a loan with exorbitant rates."
Cory Streisinger, director of the Oregon Department of Consumer & Business Services, said the number of such businesses has doubled to 360 since 2001 and they made about 750,000 loans in 2004.
She said there are Internet loan companies operating out of Grenada and elsewhere that tap the wages of late payers, a practice illegal in Oregon.
"If the loan is legal where it is made, it is exempt from our reach," she said.
Streisinger recommended capping the total that can be borrowed and establishing a database system to monitor outstanding loans to see that caps are not exceeded by use of multiple lenders. As it stands, she said, there is a "safe harbor" provision limiting payments on any one loan to 25 percent of income.
"But if you have four loans, that's 100 percent," she said.
The Oregonian, Joseph B. Frazier, AP Reporter
Related Stories - Oregon
- 'Dan Rather Reports' criticizes payday loan industry [November 23, 2006]
- Payday loan limits are long past due [November 22, 2006]
- Oregon: Report sparks interest in tightening payday loan rules [November 21, 2006]
- State promoting alternatives to payday loans [August 11, 2006]
- Keizer will await 2007 payday-loan law [August 9, 2006]
- Oregon Governor promotes ... payday loan alternatives [July 28, 2006]
- An unjust assault on payday loan industry [July 7, 2006]
- We owe more thought to payday loan issue [July 6, 2006]
- Payday lenders look for ways around cap [July 2, 2006]
- Oregon City officials look to set limits on payday loans [June 7, 2006]
- Keep lid on payday loans [May 20, 2006]
- Industry to fight payday loan limits [April 22, 2006]
- Motivations questioned in payday-loan vote [April 21, 2006]
- Payday loan regulations win final approval [April 20, 2006]
- Payday loan reform heats up [April 19, 2006]
- Group asks for strong payday loan law or nothing at all [April 13, 2006]
- Payday loans under fire for high interest charges [April 12, 2006]
- Loans that come easy can go bad fast [March 24, 2006]
- Reformers take aim at payday loan rates [February 28, 2006]
- Catholic leaders call payday loan outfits 'predatory' ... [January 19, 2006]
- Witnesses call for lending limits [January 12, 2006]
- Oregon payday loan shops under fire from officials [December 13, 2005]
See: Recent News | Archived News | RSS Newsfeeds | News by State
Go to PLIWatch.org home.